Cookie Incredible

We specialize in custom made sugar cookies!

We offer several design options for all occasions. We also welcome you to bring us your design and ideas. We can create just about any cookie design there is - within reason of course!

PRICING:

Prices start at $65 per dozen cookies and depend on final design choices. We offer custom logos, airbrushed designs/accents, hand painting, metallic colors and heavily detailed cookies for an additional cost.

We require a minimum of 12 cookies per order. Our cookies typically start at $6 a cookie. We offer platters and individually bagged cookies for favors etc. Customization is an additional charge (labels, bows etc.)

Your prices seem high for just a cookie.....

Do They?

Our lawn maintenance costs $35.00 for a ten minute cut. Many of us go to Starbucks or Dunkin and are willing to pay $6.00 for a coffee/latte/frap and that takes minutes to make. Pizza is at least $3.00 to $4.00 a slice and costs pocket change to make. Our cookies are hand made, hand decorated, hand painted and take several hours to create.

Making custom cookies takes time; several days actually. Countless hours making cutters, discussing design, stencil creation, project planning, consultations; oh did we mention baking? Then we have to make the icing, mix colors, create different consistencies, bag each one; 20 minutes each color!

Our time is valuable and our cookies are not only delicious but works of art! Our prices are good!

To book a slot on our calendar contact us today!

Contact Cookie Incredible

Frequently Asked Questions

Please reach us at cookieincrediblenj@gmail.com if you cannot find an answer to your question.

How far in advance do I need to place an order?

All special occasion orders must be placed at least 2 weeks in advance. We do accommodate for rush orders for a fee of $15.00.

Do I need to place a deposit?

Yes! A 50% NONREFUNDABLE deposit is required at the time of ordering to lock in your date. No exceptions

When do I need to pay the remainder of my balance?

Payment in full is appreciated at anytime, however we require payment in full 2 days prior to your event.

Can I make changes to my order?

Yes. All changes must be made 7 days prior to the day of event.

Do you offer delivery?

No. Currently we are a pick-up only. Please contact us for more information.

When can I pick up my order?

All orders must be picked up at the agreed upon location and scheduled time. More information will be available when we discuss your order.

How big are your cookies?

We like a decent sized cookie! Our cookies range in size based on the theme but most of our cookies start at 4 inches in size and can be as large as you want but prices will increase the bigger the cookie grows!

Can you design a cookie for me?

Yes! We specialize in custom designs but never be intimated to send us your ideas, We are always looking for new ideas and inspirations!

Baked Goods Allergy Disclaimer

Cookie Incredible cookies are produced in a home kitchen not subject to public health inspection that may also process common food allergens.

Common food allergens that may be found in the kitchen include: eggs, dairy and wheat. Soy may be present, as it may be found within an ingredient used, such as sprinkles, for example. While our baked goods do not contain peanuts or tree nuts cross contamination of these ingredients may occur.

Should you have an allergy concern, please contact us at cookieincrediblenj@gmail.com